Experience the taste of authentic Italian cuisine right in Medford, New York. From our classic Margherita pizza to our savory lasagna, every dish is made with love and the freshest ingredients.
Our Best Pizzas
Margarita Pizza Pie
House Special Pizza (Choice of 5 toppings)
Grandma Pie (House Special)
Some of our Favorite Dishes
Veal Francese
Eggplant Rollatini
Eggplant Parmigiana
Delicious Pizza and Home Style Cooking, just like Grandma used to make.
Andrew Linick Restaurant Critic
Practical Gourment Magazine
A pizza slice from Big Italy Pizzarea keeps sadness away. I would drive an extra mile for a pizza pie for Big Italy.
Ron Kapon
New York City Food & Wine Editor
It's like being in Italy
Scott Buchter
Food Editor New York Sportscene Magazine
One of the best Pizza in the USA" Big Italy Pizzeria is a Long Island landmark